Soft&StrongBy Betty Keren
← MBSR with Betty
Class · Week 5

Class #5 -  Reacting vs. Responding

Reacting vs. Responding

As we become more skilled at returning to the sensation of the breath in the body to feel the actual experience of the present moment, it may become possible to respond deliberately to stressors rather than reacting automatically.

Interactions with others can be particularly charged. This week we begin an exploration of communication and focus on interpersonal interactions.

Awareness of our thoughts as just thoughts is a particularly powerful tool. Increased awareness can help us determine when it’s worth our time and energy to reach mutual understanding and when it’s time to simply “drop the hat” and let it go.

How might mindfulness help us find ways to

respond mindfully

instead of

reacting mindlessly

and habitually as we navigate the challenges, concerns, and joys of the day?

Practices

Homework

  • Open awareness practice
  • Bring awareness to moments of reacting and explore options for responding with greater mindfulness, spaciousness, and creativity. Remember the breath: a great anchor and support to slow down and make more conscious choices.
  • Pay attention to communication and interaction with others and fill out the “Challenging Communication” calendar (next page) and reflect on a challenging or stressful communication experience each day. How did you respond?
<a class="notion-file" href="https://prod-files-secure.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/2f9c0bef-7670-81d7-aaf5-000370a71fe5/2a5fcb64-9803-4db6-abca-40f939adc5c5/Communications-Calendar.pdf?X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&amp;X-Amz-Content-Sha256=UNSIGNED-PAYLOAD&amp;X-Amz-Credential=ASIAZI2LB466QU7RIWDR%2F20260610%2Fus-west-2%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&amp;X-Amz-Date=20260610T101113Z&amp;X-Amz-Expires=3600&amp;X-Amz-Security-Token=IQoJb3JpZ2luX2VjEBoaCXVzLXdlc3QtMiJIMEYCIQC88sBzcHqAAdmj0Is4Turgs%2BokHcCqjBFL1VaRu%2Ft%2F0QIhAMGoPl%2FytECt3yCtelStVCpTqHUbA4Yw0NKNupBfCzuyKogECOP%2F%2F%2F%2F%2F%2F%2F%2F%2F%2FwEQABoMNjM3NDIzMTgzODA1IgyMqZYxc7E8yXxQH54q3ANViHeqoYso29uI%2FHRF9%2FQoW7W2qH4Shz5sBARgY8e01c4%2BGprNxPpRO%2FpjSt3mnx45qtEIla0QNEmf4LudH3iUN9bYMY%2F8vYQinjzrUsgHjuFmLi9kkJzMP%2ByG%2FDQFCeMpz%2FuoHrvkZ94m5HWmOdW8HEqadUukrwPFOcA2l7LAS27ngefiERdXJ39Ty1xsxVeEl0qSVujl3MUIM77RG%2Bonara68t7Hp0BClnZLZ0184uFFqoI5wxC0jWZWI3k6oklkOwFl1R8yqZpIrmJa0kOLqxpH09YqOGAs9EAJUa0mx%2Bmer9my5wW1Xr6bri8ol0R8QpEPU5O142sfp%2FX%2Fz62jlBfzsNVcijpWxOOAsouojJjgt%2FNeBrM7W9%2FZewi5GLl7mM0qVtQ%2BWSmQ2wStQzvLFY6jQnT94IuuoOY59CrKUsGBfEbRFOprtuGirMBzz%2FCfsBYdzsLF9eil0zyjgiWJyuDp97F757wqFHYz3dZDYAhTumBdSqO8aGt8a%2BrWhwIDMBDZSg2dGoQPliJEVgZeQemJd36XHtytPw58dUXUh65UXfeGjIevwmZjeF8r9wO9hMSmE9JVH%2FOO0oD9q4AvZTLD6RquD2dPlavNRFWemdP3lEILbFbKtlXeTTDv4aTRBjqkAc4vHtUCzOIAWHBXu1QxLaRPjftBYymBCMuM5%2B7nCt7XYjZK%2F5sa%2FdBnnXJQfcZvGLSpW9lOpFBpXBiuLKDoKb8LSrVfD4Q%2Bj3P6X48e8udrc0b7gK5ntz7CRZc8Ag3%2BOs1cG7bv6IM3iCGAvyVhIjCNa0g2ptrVjVRgO2xCoPD%2FSljA3Q8Ej7bb4FTwLYxH1RFdiM4Edgt7GK%2B74mFLOpLCi2%2Fn&amp;X-Amz-Signature=9f62e6236e05a0620887a5eea62fd4b4ae0cc468c5ca48ad992a9b1c451a07df&amp;X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&amp;x-amz-checksum-mode=ENABLED&amp;x-id=GetObject" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">↓ Communications-Calendar.pdf</a>

image.png

The Story Your Brain Keeps Telling

There is a part of the brain that scientists call the Default Mode Network.

It sounds technical, but the idea behind it is deeply human.

This is the network that becomes active when the mind has nothing specific to focus on. It is where the brain naturally drifts when we are not fully present with what is happening right now.

Jon Kabat-Zinn and more teachers describe it beautifully as:

“The story of me, in the key of me, starring me, narrated by me.”

It is the inner narrator constantly commenting, remembering, replaying, predicting, and imagining.

And while this system is not bad, it has a tendency to pull us away from the present moment.


Why the Mind Drifts Into the Past and Future

The Default Mode Network often takes us into two directions:

The Past

This is where we revisit conversations, replay mistakes, hold onto regret, guilt, blame, or old pain.

The mind thinks it is trying to protect us by reviewing what happened.

But sometimes it keeps us stuck there.

The Future

This is where worry lives.

“What if something goes wrong?”

“What if I fail?”

“What if I’m not enough?”

The brain begins creating scenarios that have not happened yet, and the body responds as if they are real.

This is why anxiety can feel so physical.


The Brain’s Negativity Bias

Human beings are naturally wired to notice danger more than comfort.

Thousands of years ago, this helped us survive.

A brain that remembered threats was more likely to stay alive.

But in modern life, that same survival system can turn inward.

It can make the mind focus more on:

  • Problems instead of possibilities
  • Fear instead of safety
  • Criticism instead of compassion

The brain is not broken for doing this.

It is simply doing what it was designed to do.

The challenge is learning how to gently guide it somewhere else.


The Other Network: Presence

Researchers also discovered another system in the brain called the Task Positive Network.

Unlike the Default Mode Network, this part becomes active when we focus on something happening right now.

And the beautiful part is:

It does not take much.

A single breath.

Feeling your feet on the ground.

Listening closely to a sound.

Wiggling your toes.

Noticing the air on your skin.

Small acts of awareness shift the brain.

The moment attention moves into the senses, the mind begins returning to the present.


You Cannot Be Fully Present and Fully Lost in Thought at the Same Time

One of the most powerful ways to understand these two brain networks is through breathing.

You cannot inhale and exhale at the exact same moment.

One naturally softens so the other can happen.

The brain works in a similar way.

When we strengthen present-moment awareness, the constant mental storytelling begins to quiet down.

Not through force.

Not through suppression.

But through attention.


Mindfulness Is Not About Stopping Thoughts

Many people believe mindfulness means “clearing the mind.”

But the mind was never meant to be empty.

Thoughts will come.

Memories will appear.

Worries will visit.

The practice is not about shutting the brain off.

The practice is noticing when we are lost in the story and gently returning to what is real right now.

A breath.

A sound.

A sensation.

A step.

Again and again.


Every Time You Return to the Present, You Change the Brain

Neuroscience now shows that repeated attention reshapes neural pathways.

In simple terms:

What we practice becomes easier to access.

Every time you pause and reconnect with the present moment, you strengthen the pathways connected to calm, awareness, and regulation.

Over time, the brain becomes less trapped in automatic rumination.

Even the Default Mode Network itself begins to shift.

The mind learns a new pattern.


The Sensory World vs. The Narrative

One of the deepest lessons in mindfulness is this:

There is a difference between reality and the story we place on top of reality.

For example:

  • Feeling tension in your chest is real.
  • The thought “Everything is falling apart” is the narrative.

The sensation happens first.

The interpretation follows.

And often, suffering grows more from the story than from the moment itself.

This is why mindfulness invites us back into the sensory world:

  • What can you hear?
  • What can you feel?
  • What can you see?
  • What is actually here right now?

Because presence interrupts the spiral.


Small Anchors Matter More Than We Think

People often imagine transformation as something dramatic.

But the nervous system responds most powerfully to small, repeated moments of safety and awareness.

A slow breath.

A hand on the heart.

Feet touching the floor.

A moment of stillness before reacting.

These are not tiny things to the brain.

They are signals.

Signals that say:

“You are here now.”

“You are safe enough to return.”

“You do not have to live inside every thought.”


A Beautiful Reminder

The mind will wander.

That is what minds do.

But every time you notice it and gently come back to the present moment, something meaningful is happening inside you.

Not just emotionally.

Neurologically.

You are practicing a different way of being.

And maybe healing does not always begin with changing your whole life.

Maybe it begins with noticing one breath before the next thought pulls you away.